Guide
How to Prevent AI Cheating on Take-Home Case Studies and Modeling Tests
10 minute read - Published: October 2026 - Updated: November 2026
The take-home case study used to be the most honest part of the process: a candidate alone with a dataset and a deadline, producing work you could judge. In 2025 that stopped being true. A model can build the three-statement model, write the investment memo and draft the deck in an afternoon, and a candidate can have a friend or a paid service do it with no trace. Firms have responded by dropping take-homes, which throws away the best signal they had. This guide sets out three controls that keep the take-home and make it trustworthy again.
Why take-homes broke in 2025
Three things changed at once. General-purpose AI models became good enough to produce finished analytical work from a prompt and a file. Desktop assistants and overlays made it possible to use them inside any application without a browser trail. And the market for outsourced case work, which always existed, became cheap and fast. A take-home that was a test of the candidate's skill became a test of the candidate's access to tools.
The three ways candidates cheat on a take-home
The first is AI generation: the candidate pastes the prompt and the data into a model and edits the output. The second is outsourcing: a tutor, a former analyst or a paid service does the work. The third is collaboration: several candidates share a solution. Each leaves a different trace. AI generation shows in the writing and in a machine record that an assistant ran during the work. Outsourcing shows when the candidate cannot explain their own analysis. Collaboration shows in matching structure across submissions.
Control 1: Set the rules and say they will be checked
Write the rules into the assignment: what tools are allowed, what are not, whether AI assistance is permitted for any part, and that the work and the process will be reviewed. Most candidates follow rules that are stated. More importantly, a stated rule turns a later finding into a policy matter rather than an argument about what was fair. Keep the wording short, put it at the top of the brief, and have the candidate acknowledge it before the files are released.
Control 2: Verify the author in a short live follow-up
A fifteen-minute conversation in which the candidate walks through their own model answers the outsourcing question better than any detector. Ask why an assumption was chosen, what breaks if a driver changes, and what they would do with another hour. A candidate who did the work answers easily. One who did not cannot. This also makes the take-home fairer to strong candidates, who get a chance to show reasoning the written submission could not.
Control 3: Use software that records what ran on the machine and reviews what was submitted
The third control closes the gap the first two leave. The candidate works in a monitored session, launched from the assignment link, that records which applications and extensions ran, whether an AI assistant or overlay was present, whether a remote-control session or virtual machine was in use, and when focus moved away from the work. Screen and webcam recording are optional and stated in advance. When the work is submitted, a content review reads it for signs of AI generation and produces a written finding with its reasoning. The session report and the content finding go to the reviewer together with the follow-up notes.
What this looks like in practice at a bank or fund
The brief goes out with the rules and a launch link. The candidate installs the application, sees the consent notice and works as usual over the allowed window. At submission, the reviewer receives a report: device and session details, the applications observed with timestamps, any restricted-tool or remote-access events, the content review of the submitted files, and a session score. The live follow-up is scheduled for the next day. The hiring decision is made with all three inputs, and the file holds the evidence if the decision is ever questioned.
What candidates see
A short notice stating what is recorded and for how long, a one-click launch, and their normal tools. No keystroke logging, no file reading, nothing outside the session window. Candidates who do their own work gain a credible record that they did; that is worth more to them than it is to the firm.
Checklist
Rules at the top of the brief, acknowledged before files are released. A stated list of permitted tools. A monitored session for the working window with screen and webcam settings decided and disclosed in advance. Content review on submission. A fifteen-minute live walkthrough within a day or two. The same process for every candidate at the stage. The reviewer's conclusion written down.
Frequently asked questions
Can AI-written case studies be detected?
Partly from the writing, and reliably from the machine record. A content review reads the submission for signs of AI generation; the session report shows whether an assistant ran during the work. Together with a live walkthrough, the three inputs are hard to beat.
Should we stop using take-home case studies?
No. A take-home is the best measure of applied skill a firm has. The fix is to add the controls above, not to remove the test.
Is monitoring a candidate's computer during a take-home acceptable?
With notice and consent, and limited to the working session, it is widely used. The notice states what is checked and what is not. Firms should confirm wording with counsel for their jurisdictions.
Does the software read the candidate's files?
No. It records which applications and windows were present and when, and optionally screen and webcam if enabled. The content review reads only the files the candidate submits.
What if the candidate uses a second computer?
The live walkthrough is the control for that case. A candidate who cannot explain their own work has answered the question regardless of which machine produced it.
Can AI assistance be allowed for part of the work?
Yes, if the rules say so. Many firms permit AI for formatting or research and prohibit it for the analysis. State the line clearly and the report shows what ran.
See a session, a detection, and a report
A short walkthrough of a live exam, a flagged moment, and the finding your integrity office would receive.
